Why is This Debunked Evolutionary Theory so Persistent?
The AAH suggests our ancestors were once partially aquatic. (Source: Renato Bender)
About five million years ago, a shifting climate forced our ancestors to abandon their arboreal lifestyles, as African forests shifted into swathes of grasslands. Forced into migration, these ancestors evolved the upright bipedal posture we maintain today. This is called the Savannah Hypothesis, and remains the most popular theory to account for our bipedalism, but the consensus is not total. A controversial theory suggests that modern humans were not sculpted by the African savannah, but by the ocean; that our ancestors were once partially aquatic.
This theory is called the Aquatic Ape Hypothesis and suggests that bipedalism (along with many other human adaptations) can be accounted for by a period in our evolution when our ancestors lived an aquatic lifestyle. AAH has been controversial since its origin in 1960, largely ignored by most anthropologists but championed by a vocal minority. To be clear, AAH has been debunked as gaps in the fossil record have closed, but it is worth examining to pin down why some tenuous theories can hold the sway that they do, even when their evidence is faulty.
A human and gorilla skeleton compared. The origin of bipedalism is at the center of AAH. (Source: Encyclopædia Britannica)
AAH holds its origins in a 1960 New Scientist article by marine biologist Alister Hardy, later championed by feminist Elain Morgan in 1982’s The Aquatic Ape, as it ran counter to the questionable, patriarchy-tinged Naked Ape theory. Hardy and Morgan asserted that a dearth of fossils during the time period when modern humans diverged from apes could be explained from a single source—humans did not evolve their unique traits slowly, but all at once. Shifting sea levels required humans to become partially aquatic for a period of time—when the seas receded, we carried these traits with us.
Under the wide AAH umbrella hypothesis, nearly every last human adaptation can be explained by a time in our history when we lived in the water. Lack of body hair made swimming easier, more fat made us more buoyant, and wading eased us into bipedalism. Unfortunately for AAH’s champions, today’s more robust fossil record proves these traits evolved separately across a long period of time. Lack of body hair and higher fat levels allowed for greater thermoregulation on the savannah, while bipedalism may owe itself to lengthening of limbs needed for tree-climbing.
There are still plenty of questions to be had regarding human evolution—the Savannah Hypothesis is not universally accepted and there are different theories for our individual adaptations. The AAH case is useful as a reminder of the faultiness in seeking out one model to account for every last human adaptation. Perhaps that is why the theory remains popular, the idea of humans being a unique species created by a single unique circumstance can be more attractive than the chaotic randomness of evolution.
Featured Product
Alamosaurus Bone - Classic Riker Display Case Fragment
Latest News
-
May 30, 2025 Learn how Scientists Used Zircon Crystals to Date a Meteorite Impact! Read More -
May 19, 2025 Scientists at CERN Are Split-Second Alchemists Read More -
May 16, 2025 Scientists Capture First Ever Recording of a Live Coelacanth in Indonesia! Read More -
May 08, 2025 Scientists Find Evidence of a Real-Life Tatooine! Read More -
Apr 27, 2025 Lyndon Johnson: Architect of the U.S. Space Program Read More -
Apr 23, 2025 Can I Lick It? Yes You Can! Read More
Cool Things!
Learn how Scientists Used Zircon Crystals to Date a Meteorite Impact!
In a new study, researchers have observed that a meteorite impact in modern day Scotland, thought to have occurred 1.2 billion years ago, was actually much more recent, at around 990 million years ago. Their method: studying the microscopic zircon crystals that they say “captured the impact.”
Scientists at CERN Are Split-Second Alchemists
Although they won’t be turning a profit anytime soon, scientists at CERN have become split-second alchemists, briefly turning lead particles into gold.
Scientists Capture First Ever Recording of a Live Coelacanth in Indonesia!
A living fossil, the Coelacanth is one of the most elusive and fascinating known sea creatures. Scientists have long known of two main species of Coelacanth, Latimeria chalumnae, native to the West Indian Ocean, and Latimeria menadoensis, native to Indonesia. While the Western Indian Coelacanth has been photographed, its Indonesian counterpart was recently photographed for the first time.
Specimen Deep Dives
Returning to the Moon: The Apollo 14 Mission
The Secrets of the Space Shuttle: Learn about Mini Museum's Shuttle Tile Material!
Gondwana: When the Earth Was One
Long Form Articles
Can I Lick It? Yes You Can!
Have you ever been unable to tell if a fossil was really a fossil, but you were too embarrassed to admit it? Have you ever wanted to lick a fossil just because, but you didn’t want to risk judgment from your peers? Well, good news! You can kill two birds with one stone! Licking a fossil can actually help you determine if it’s the real deal or just another rock.
Is It Legal To Own a Meteorite: How to Start Your Outer Space Collection!
Meteorites are some of the rarest geological specimens to be found on Earth. Of course, since these stones are not of our world, purchasing them can sometimes be a confusing process. Is it legal to own a meteorite? In short, yes! Read on for help starting your cosmic collection!
Is It Legal To Own a Dinosaur Fossil? How to start your Dinosaur Collection!
So you want to start fossil collecting!? Amateur paleontology is a fascinating and fun hobby that can even nab you an award! Dinosaur bones are some of the most sought-after specimens in the world, so you may be wondering, is it even legal to own a dinosaur bone? In short, yes! Read on for more help starting your fossil collection!